Shop Eye Makeup

Check out the latest eye makeup from top brands like Tarte, Stila, Smashbox and more. Go from mild to wild with our large selection of eye makeup from liners to mascaras to shadows to false lashes and more!

Sort by:
Peter Thomas Roth Lashes To Die For THE MASCARA
$22.00
Why We Love It:

Do your lashes need all the help they can get? This mascara will nourish and give even sparse lashes to-die-for drama.

4.65
Smashbox Full Exposure Mascara
Why We Love It:

"Everything you could want from a mascara: definition, volume, length, no flakes, plus it's easy to remove." JRB, CO

4.25
Tarte Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara
$23.00
Why We Love It:

Natural Amazonian clay keeps this ultra-volumizing mascara flake-free, while hydrating and strengthening brittle lashes.

4.25
Laura Geller GlamLASH Dramatic Volumizing Mascara
$24.00
Why We Love It:

"Goes on smoothly, no clumps and makes my lashes look longer than I ever thought. My favorite mascara!" lad6865, PA

4.45
100% Pure Mascara
$25.00
Why We Love It:

It may be all natural, but this mascara doesn't skimp on the drama, giving you longer, thicker lashes that don't smudge.

4.45
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
Was: $22.00 - $22.00
Now: $16.50 - $22.00
Why We Love It:

Make your mark on great makeup. This waterproof liner uses a marker-like tip for an easy, long-lasting look.

4.55
Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner
Was: $22.00 - $22.00
Now: $16.50 - $22.00
Why We Love It:

For high-impact style, BB loves to kick it up a notch with these intense, eye-catching liners that stay vibrant and stay put.

4.65
Anastasia DIPBROW Pomade
$18.00
Why We Love It:

Channel your inner makeup artist and sculpt, color and carve your way to show-stopping brows.

5.05
Elizabeth Arden Grand Entrance Mascara
$25.00
Why We Love It:

Lengthen those lashes and get amplified curl, lift and volume with this water-resistant mascara.

4.65
Tarte Lights, Camera, Splashes Waterproof Mascara
$23.00
Why We Love It:

Make a splash in this volumizing mascara! It resists water and gives your lashes length, curl and conditioning benefits.

4.35
Eyeko Rock Out and Lash Out Mascara
$26.00
Why We Love It:

Be prepared to join the band with lash-defining mascara that won't clump or flake, giving you rock star eyes every day.

4.75
Anastasia Tinted Brow Gel
$22.00
Why We Love It:

Achieve a brow above the rest with this tinted brow gel.

4.85
philosophy just release me eye makeup remover
$19.00
Why We Love It:

After a few gentle sweeps, watch every last trace of even caked-on makeup become history.

4.35
Smashbox Always Sharp Waterproof Kohl Liner
$21.00
Why We Love It:

There's never a dull day for this liner. Eyes always stay sharp with crisp dramatic lines and stunning definition.

3.05
Anastasia Brow Powder Duo
$23.00
Why We Love It:

Take brows from boring to beautiful with these shades that help create a perfect, customized brow color.

4.85
Tarte Picture Perfect Eyelash Curler
$18.00
Why We Love It:

Many BBers swear this is the best curler they've ever encountered. And when used with the mascara, the results are eye-opening.

5.05
Tarte Amazonian Clay Waterproof Brow Pencil
$21.00
Why We Love It:

Get brows in high-def! The super-slim pencil adds nourishing color to mimic hairs " and it's waterproof to last all day.

4.85
Anastasia Brow Definer
$23.00
Why We Love It:

BB Loves: So quick and easy - simply outline the shape of your brow and use the bristled end to blend the color inward towards the center of the brow.

Tarte Tartelette Amazonian Clay Matte Palette
$39.00
Why We Love It:

Hypnotizing eyes are just a shadow away. Express your sultry side with this shadow set featuring 12 smoldering shades.

Anastasia Perfect Brow Pencil
$23.00
Why We Love It:

Just two easy steps to beautiful brows! Apply natural color with the pencil; then flip it to brush and blend.

5.05
Smashbox Photo Op Under Eye Brightener - Nude
$20.00
Why We Love It:

BB Tip: This sheer formula works best before concealer or wear alone on the face wherever you want an added glow.

4.55
Per-fekt Eye Perfection Gel
Was: $45.00
Now: $22.50
Why We Love It:

While raccoons are cute, keep your own dark eye circles at bay with per-fekt eye gel.

4.65
Stila Eye Shadow Compact
$18.00
Why We Love It:

A feast for your eyes! From classic neutrals to eye-catching colors, create your favorite looks with these compacts.

4.95
Smashbox Brow Tech To Go
$28.00
Why We Love It:

Don"t let brows be a hassle while on the go with this portable, travel-friendly applicator.

5.05
Smashbox Mini Full Exposure Palette
$25.00
Why We Love It:

Discover the perfect neutral shades for amazing eyes. Create dazzling looks with this palette of eye shadow colors.

Anastasia Beauty Express for Brows and Eyes
$39.50
Why We Love It:

Everything you need for perfectly groomed brows on the go is right here in one convenient place with an included mirror.

4.75
Smashbox Full Exposure Palette
$52.00
Why We Love It:

Open your eyes to 14 shades of sensational. Create awesome looks with these neutrals that range from mattes to shimmers.

5.05
  • Refine by:
  • Clear
    Brand
    • 100% Pure (6)
    • Anastasia (12)
    • Ardell (27)
    • Bare Minerals (13)
    • Beauty Blender (1)
    • Clarins (9)
    • Elizabeth Arden Beauty (4)
    • Eyeko (1)
    • Laura Geller (13)
    • NYX Cosmetics (22)
    • PerFekt (2)
    • Peter Thomas Roth (1)
    • Sigma Beauty (5)
    • Smashbox (23)
    • Stila (16)
    • Tarte (33)
    • Too Faced Cosmetics (1)
    • Tweezerman (3)
    • philosophy (1)
  • Category
    • Brow Enhancers
    • Concealers
    • False Lashes
    • Liners
    • Mascara
    • Palettes
    • Shadow
    • Shadow Primer
    • Eyelash Curlers
  • Clear
    Pricing
    • $10.00 & Under (44)
    • $15.00 & Under (70)
    • $25.00 & Under (153)
    • $50.00 & Under (191)
    • $75.00 & Under (193)
    • $100.00 & Under (193)